What Can Vehicle Diagnostics Reveal About Your Car’s Health?

Shade Tree Garage

The computerized vehicle diagnostic system, often referred to as an On-Board Diagnostics (OBD) system, is a sophisticated piece of technology that plays a crucial role in maintaining the health of your vehicle. In this month’s blog, we discuss how the OBD may not always pinpoint the source of your vehicle’s problem without further exploration by a trained service professional.

How does the OBD system work?

The OBD system works by continuously receiving and analyzing data from various sensors located throughout the vehicle. These sensors measure everything from engine temperature to oxygen levels in the exhaust gases.


When you connect an OBD scanner to your vehicle (usually via a port under the dashboard), you can access these trouble codes. Each code corresponds to a specific problem, which can then be diagnosed and fixed by a service professional.

Are the OBD codes always accurate?

When a vehicle’s computer reports a problem, it is common for drivers to assume that the computer has identified the faulty component and that replacing it will fix the issue. However, this is not always the case.


Often, there is a reason for the code that is not the result of a component failure. For example, if a vehicle has a bad thermostat, it may trigger a code for a coolant sensor out of range. The computer expects a certain signal after a few minutes of running time, which it may not receive because the engine failed to reach operating temperature. Similarly, if an engine stalls, the crank position sensor may report a loss of speed signal. However, the crank sensor is reporting the fact that the engine stopped running and changing that sensor would not fix the stalling.

Verifying OBD readings

Because the OBD readings may not always pinpoint the problem, it is important to perform a thorough diagnosis before replacing any components. A visual inspection can help identify any obvious issues. If nothing is apparent, further testing may be required to determine the exact reason for the check engine light, or malfunction indicator light (MIL).


For instance, if you get a code for loss of signal from the camshaft actuator, it is important to perform a visual inspection and fault memory read before replacing any components. In some cases, small rodents may have moved in under the hood of your car and eaten all sorts of stuff causing issues with your car.

See the photos below of a recent example where the diagnostic did not tell the entire story.

The pictures show an example of a recent camshaft indicator error that turned out to be damage from rodents.


To ensure that your vehicle is properly serviced, it is important not to jump to conclusions when your vehicle’s computer reports an issue. Instead, take your car to an experienced technician who can perform a thorough diagnosis and recommend appropriate testing to determine the exact reason for the MIL.


If you would like to have your vehicle inspected for possible issues, contact the service professionals at Shade Tree Garage to schedule an appointment.

Technician checking tire pressure in a clean bay
By Samantha Boylls • October 12, 2026
Learn why your tire pressure light comes on during the first cold October morning, how to check pressure safely, and when a recurring warning needs attention.
Technician checking a car heater in a clean Morristown auto repair shop
By Samantha Boylls • October 5, 2026
Learn five possible reasons your car heater blows cold or weak as Morristown temperatures drop—and when to stop driving or bring it to Shade Tree Garage.
Classic car in a clean Morristown shop bay for fall maintenance.
September 28, 2026
Learn how to prepare your classic car for fall driving or storage with our ASE-certified technician's checklist, covering ZDDP oil, tires, and fluids.
Modern vehicle on a professional lift in a Morristown NJ auto repair shop
September 21, 2026
Worried about brake noise? Learn what squealing, grinding, and pulsing mean from our ASE-certified techs in Morristown. Expert tips on when to seek brake repair.
Mechanic using a diagnostic scan tool on a European car dashboard
September 14, 2026
Expert advice from ASE-certified technicians on maintaining your BMW, Porsche, Mercedes, or Audi after summer heat. Learn about cooling systems, fluids, and belts.
ASE certified technician performing a fall car maintenance inspection in Morristown NJ.
September 7, 2026
Prepare your vehicle for winter with our expert fall car maintenance checklist. Learn about battery health, fluids, and more from Shade Tree Garage.
August 31, 2026
Prepare your vehicle for New Jersey's changing seasons with expert seasonal maintenance in Morristown, NJ. Learn how Shade Tree Garage helps keep your car safe and reliable year-round.
By Shade Tree Garage • August 25, 2026
Our team spent a day cooking and serving meals at Homeless Solutions in Morristown — our second year volunteering, with next year already booked.
August 17, 2026
Keep your business moving with professional fleet maintenance in Morristown, NJ. Learn how Shade Tree Garage helps reduce downtime, improve safety, and extend the life of commercial vehicles.
August 10, 2026
Looking for hybrid or electric vehicle service in Morristown, NJ? Learn how proper maintenance and diagnostics help keep your hybrid or EV safe, reliable, and performing at its best.
Show More